By TheCriticalMind
Community
REPUBLISHED BY:
The Senate Judiciary Committee met today to discuss “The Gun Violence Epidemic: A Public Health Crisis.” One of the witnesses was Dr. Megan Ranney of the Yale School of Public Health. One of her interrogators was Sen. John Kennedy (R-LA).
No one who follows these things foresaw a substantive discussion aimed at lowering America's stratospheric gun death rate. Kennedy did not buck the prediction. As sure as the sunrise, he brought up Chicago.
Kennedy laid the groundwork for his distraction with vivid but inflammatory language designed to appeal to emotion over reason — “largest outdoor shooting range.” He also added dog whistle racism. Hunters vs. inner-city gangbangers? Guess who MAGA identifies as the white group.
“Let me ask you this. Why do you think that Chicago has become America's largest outdoor shooting range? Do you think it's because of Chicago citizens, who have no criminal record, but who lawfully have a gun in their homes for protection, or perhaps for hunting? Or do you think it's because of a finite group of criminals who have rap sheets as long as King Kong’s arm?”
His most egregious misdirection was statistical. Chicago is the conservative poster child for democratically-run cities with lots of murders. In terms of absolute numbers, this is fair. With 692, Chicago had more homicides than any other US city in 2022 — higher than NY with 433 and Los Angeles with 382.
However, meaningful comparisons require per capita statistics. And by that metric, Chicago is behind 13 other US cities in homicide rate. Two of these killing fields (I take my cues from Kennedy) are from Kennedy’s home state. New Orleans is #4. Baton Rouge is #5. Both of these outdoor shooting ranges have murder rates twice that of Chicago.
Dr. Ranney made the same statistical point at the state level:
“So Mississippi, Louisiana, Missouri actually have higher firearm death rates, obviously there's certain … ”
Kennedy interrupted her. He was not going to let facts distract from his polemic. For the record, Louisiana is the second most murderous state. It is also the third lowest in life expectancy — one of the nine red states on the top ten list of places where citizens die young.
Ranney replied it was not her area of expertise. Nevertheless, Kennedy was determined to keep the focus away from the violence in his own backyard.
Kennedy: “What about Chicago?”
Ranney: “So I don't live in Chicago. It's not my primary area of research.”
Kennedy: “You don't have an opinion on that?”
Ranney then made the point that gun deaths are caused by guns. She also, being an academic and not a politician, tried to answer the question she was asked.
“I think there is easy access to firearms, combined with environmental conditions and lack of great education. There have actually been studies showing that when you green vacant lots and repair abandoned buildings in urban neighborhoods, you see decreases in gunshots and violence as well as decreases in stress and depression in the neighborhoods around them.”
Kennedy, well aware that his intended audience wanted smackdowns, not discussion, dissed Ranney while piously insisting he was not dissing her:
“No disrespect Doc, but that sounds a lot like word salad to me.”
What word salad? Ranney’s answer was grammatical, well-structured, responsive, and easily understandable. Kennedy knew it. So he slimed it. Not just with his words. He offered his dismissive scorn while ignoring her and riffling a sheaf of papers for no purpose beyond theatrics.
When liberals look at the Republican wasteland in the Age of MAGA, they see orange ass-kissing, low-IQ loudmouths baying at the moon. It is a reasonable analysis. Rabid self-promoters are the most clangorous conservative demographic. But other zealots play a quieter game. Many are intelligent, well-educated, and mercilessly dedicated to restoring an antebellum America.
One is John Kennedy.
This cotton-chewing, aw-shucks, good old boy would love you to think him a hick. He is not. He may have been raised near South Louisiana’s swampland, but he bettered himself. He went from high school co-valedictorian to president of his senior class at Vanderbilt. There he was named to Phi Beta Kappa and graduated magna cum laude.
He received a JD from the University of Virginia Law School of Law, where he was an executive editor of the Virginia Law Review and elected to the Order of the Coif. Ultimately, he earned a Bachelor of Civil Law degree, with first-class honours from Oxford University. There are few better-educated politicians in America.
But none of his schooling taught him to be honest or polite.
And politics has rendered him no more morally upright than the
high-school dropout Lauren Boebert. They may not look alike, but they
share the same DNA.
No comments:
Post a Comment